States Sue to Stop Paramount-Warner Bros. Merger
https://shorturl.at/F1xh8
I don’t want the Ellisons and Bari Weiss in charge of CNN, I don’t want Zaslav to get three-quarters of a billion in payment, but that does not mean this merger should be stopped.
Funny how those in Hollywood are freaking out over this merger, I didn’t hear them go ballistic when Disney purchased the assets of Fox. And the filmmaking division of Disney is such a minor part of the operation that the company no longer breaks out revenues separately.
But no one fears the future as much as those in the creative industries.
Tilly Norwood starring in a movie? Let me know how this is different from a Pixar production.
As for AI in music…enough with the freak-out, at this late date we’ve lived through digital disruption again and again in the past two and a half decades and the end result is after a period of turmoil, caused to a great degree by the major labels’ refusal to accept the future, suing not only distributors but their customers, the fans, to try and keep everybody in an overpriced CD for one good track world, revenues have returned as a result of streaming, sans all the costs of physical distribution.
As for the book business, they did a good job, along with the federal government’s antitrust division, in raising the price of e-books, going to the agency model, and the end result is not only have the sales of e-books been hampered, but the overall business is stagnant. Jeff Bezos was trying to build a business, growing the overall pot for books, and the publishers and writers didn’t want to give a techie power and ended up shooting themselves in the foot.
Then again, book publishing is a gnat on the ass of the music and movie industries.
So we had consolidation in the music business, Universal has in excess of a 30% share. More than Paramount would have after the merger. Turns out the major label game doesn’t have the power it once did. Which was based on distribution. Now anybody can get their music on streaming services essentially for free, competing with the big boys and girls. As a matter of fact, indie share keeps increasing! As for breaking new music… It’s not only the indies who are having trouble here, but the majors themselves. Actually, a good case can be made that the majors are only interested in moonshots, leaving so many genres to indies.
As far as you not getting paid what you feel you deserve, chances are you wouldn’t have been able to play at all in the old world, never mind getting a deal, but getting your music in a retail shop, and good luck getting paid as an indie if you did! You can now make the music on your laptop, essentially for free, and you can promote it online for free. This is a disaster? Then again, everybody believes they’re entitled to make a living in music. Furthermore, as a result of pure demand for a unique experience, concert ticket prices have gone into the stratosphere, far exceeding inflation. If you think you can set an artificially high price for concert tickets you’re uninformed, no one is forcing people to go, and people want to go so badly that they’ll pay a scalper much more than face value to attend.
Has the landscape changed, are winners bigger and losers smaller? Absolutely, but this is not only in music. As a result of the flattening of distribution, the removal of friction, all music is available to all people at the same price in the same place and people gravitate to hits.
Now what will the music landscape look like in the future? We’re in a period of evolution, but one thing is for sure, by refusing to enter the future, the business only hurt itself.
As for AI…
Where’s Frank Zappa when you need him? AI labels are akin to PMRC labels, only the acts of yore are the censors of today. AI is a tool. Rightsholders should be paid for the ingestion of works, one could argue that they should be able to refuse the ingestion of works, but that ship seems to have already sailed. As for the result… Demos are cheap, pros love this. As for fully AI productions, so far none has been a hit. Oh, ignore the headlines about manipulated projects where the company buys a de minimis number of tracks and the song goes to number one at the iTunes Store. That’s like having the most productive horse at the Central Park Carriage Rides.
Then again, misinformation, as well as disinformation, is a greater force than ever. This is a problem, but this does not mean we should return all power to the usual suspects of yore.
As far as Bari Weiss at CBS… She installed Tony Dokoupil as anchor on the “CBS Evening News” and not only are ratings half of those on ABC, and nowhere close to those on NBC, they’re shrinking to boot! This is what happens when people are in over their heads, when amateurs gain power, they end up destroying what they’re in control of and leaving holes for new players. Can you say “60 Minutes”?
As for news… There are more places than ever to get it. Who even watches the network TV news? And CBS got rid of its radio news division… It’s shrinking, not growing. And if you tune in CNN you get constant arguments more than hard reporting of facts.
As for the movie business…
Despite the legacy press being fascinated with film, the big story in visual media today is the encroachment of YouTube in terms of viewing share. Even Netflix is freaked out.
But YouTube is not like the movie business and not like Netflix. As a matter of fact, YouTube tried to do this and failed, green-lighting big budget productions to crickets and abandoning the business. No, YouTube is about user-generated content. Which is not what theatrical movies are, and is not what big outlet streaming is, but the public is cottoning to it.
So the major challenge to movie theatres is not consolidation of studios, but the alternatives, both TV streaming and YouTube. Who says story needs to be produced for tens and sometimes hundreds of millions of dollars when you can shoot an entire flick in 4k on your iPhone. And two of the biggest movie hits of the summer were made by young YouTubers!
So if there is consolidation of studios…
There are fewer places for people to work. The Ellisons say they’ll make 30 movies a year, but even if they don’t… Workers don’t understand, studios make what the market can hold. And theatre revenues keep going down. This is a declining business. Maybe it will survive for event pictures, but irrelevant of this merger theatres will close, there are just not enough desirable movies to keep them in business.
So what is going to happen in visual entertainment? Indies will soar and continue to eat up market share.
I mean look at Netflix itself. With no portfolio it became the biggest online streamer completely in plain sight. The studios were asleep, licensing their product as Netflix built a monolith. Should we sustain these studios at the expense of Netflix? I’m not in favor of that, and I’m sure you’re not either.
That’s what you get when you try to live in the past.
So maybe visual entertainment changes. Made by a plethora of indies on smaller budgets. Who says an actor or director should be entitled to so much per film? Look at recording budgets, they’ve fallen through the floor.
As for the canard that with one fewer studio prices to theatres will be leveraged… First, there are still four major studios left, one more than in the music business, and this is an industry that is based on customer desire. This is not milk or shoes. It all depends on hits. Raise the prices on mediocre films and what happens? NO ONE GOES!
Actually, these same people railing against this merger are the same ones who complain about RottenTomatoes… Talk about harming the consumer, they want everybody to spend their hard-earned bread to find out if a picture is good enough, wasting their time. You can research products on Amazon, all over the web, but movies are sacrosanct?
So what we’ve got here is a bunch of both above the line and below the line professionals in Hollywood who believe they’re entitled to continue to flourish at the same level of remuneration as they have in the past. Auto workers can lose their jobs, but not them. Why?
Opportunity is rampant.
Content is not king, distribution is. And on YouTube…DISTRIBUTION IS FREE! Where is the problem? You can build a new business using the new tools but that would require you to re-evaluate everything you know and get back into the trenches and do the hard work. This is almost laughable. Do I want everybody in Hollywood to be out of work? Of course not. But maintaining the old model would truly hurt the consumer.
Seems the smarter and richer you are, the more educated you are, unless you’re in tech, you’re railing against the future, wanting everything to stay the same. Yet these same people are bitching about Trump and the MAGA movement wanting to return to a fictitious past.
Where is it written that the cheese can’t be moved, no one can ever lose a dollar. That certainly ain’t America.
So when you leave emotion out, you’re left with the law.
Yes, the Trump administration has rubber-stamped mergers that needed more investigation, but that does not mean they’re wrong here.
Remember the Biden administration? They prevented Amazon from purchasing Roomba, the maker of iRobot… Yeah, that’ll show ’em, don’t let the Seattle behemoth become any bigger! But the end result is Roomba went bankrupt and now the computerized floor cleaning business is owned by the Chinese.
And then there was the blocking of the JetBlue/Spirit merger. Yup, American and United are too big already, let’s not let there be any more consolidation of power! End result? Spirit went bankrupt, out of business, and Jet Blue is struggling.
Why do Democrats always get it wrong on this stuff? They can see the issue, but not the future. If the Democrats had been in power, they would have prevented the merger of T-Mobile and Sprint…and the end result would have been Sprint going bankrupt!
But got to keep consolidation from happening…
Now creating a new telecom company would be a heavy lift. But making art and distributing it? God, the problem is that there’s now too much of this stuff! And the movie studios are always on the back foot, innovation comes from elsewhere.
As for the merged Paramount/Warner company controlling basic cable channels… They’re worth little and every day they’re worth less. What next, protecting the market for 78 RPM records?
The future cannot be stopped. And every operation that has tried to do this has ended up behind the 8-ball. Never mind those who were oblivious to the future, like Kodak. Huge market share and then…essentially nothing.
Not that I’m endorsing Trump’s killing of alternative energy and his elimination of electric car subsidies. 20% of new autos in Europe are electric. And China is eating the lunch of the European carmakers in their home territory, because they were busy banking profits rather than being nimble and investing in the future. Yes, you can buy an electric VW in China today, but it’s got fewer features and less efficient software. What’s the market demand for that?
Of course China subsidized battery and electric car development. But the U.S. used to be the leader on this, now funds for scientific discovery are being cut.
Clowns to the left of me.
Jokers to the right.
Here I am stuck in the middle with you.


