Astute. I have experienced Oasis in small clubs, and we also did a live broadcast on WBCN from the Orpheum Theatre when the band played Boston. Exceedingly dull performances every appearance. One boring band with a few good songs. Give me Blur any day.<\/p>\n
Oedipus<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I agree with everything you said about Oasis. I was at Sony when Oasis first came to America and Liam thought they were already superstars here. He wasn\u2019t happy that they\u2019d be starting at the bottom and working their way up. But, they did the work and succeeded, despite their live show being less than exciting.<\/p>\n
Drew Ferrante<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Bob, I saw the second show back in Cardiff back in July. I went to an early show because I figured they would be broken up by now. It was a fantastic show of 24ish songs that went by in a flash. I was not what you would call a massive fan but sold a bunch of Oasis back in my record store days. Saw them once at the Fox in Atlanta sometime in the late 90’s. Don’t recall being super impressed.<\/p>\n
This was different. The production and sound were incredible. The crowd energy was something I have rarely experienced in 50 years of going to shows. I count this one in my Top 5 of all times. What a fun night. I was expecting a fight and a mess. What I got was pure rock and roll. Highly recommended!<\/p>\n
Best,<\/p>\n
Don VanCleave<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I caught the show last week in Scotland, and it is just outstanding<\/p>\n
The connection the have with their fans is truly never level, it\u2019s an emotional bond that is deeper then most especially overseas.<\/p>\n
Dan\u00a0Steinberg<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Amen!<\/p>\n
I was joking on social that I love Britrock but they were mid at best. My music friends commended me \u201cfor my bravery\u201d because so many people are seeing them live. Some managers said it\u2019s nostalgia, it\u2019s what they blared in their first NYC apartment. Time and place. That makes sense to me. And hey like you, maybe I\u2019d go if I were invited – to sing the along to the two songs I hated when they played ad nauseum on the radio, because I know them very well. And even that is a kind of nostalgia that feels quaint now.<\/p>\n
This tour is lightning in a bottle. Everyone can sense we\u2019re in a pot of boiling water and Oasis represent a time when it seemed life was major chords. Champagne supernova hits that perfect utopian yearning.<\/p>\n
Noel was top notch on Twitter when that was still kicking – that\u2019s when I was on the music team there and he kept it lively!<\/p>\n
Nicole St. Jean<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
As the dad of a 20-something musician, there is a new generation of Oasis fans who is very interested in the US shows. But I remember passing on seeing them at relatively small Dallas venues.<\/p>\n
The hits are pretty great and the Live at Glastonbury film\/soundtrack is amazing. That said, US stadiums won\u2019t be full of Brits who know every word of every song, so the energy will be different over here.<\/p>\n
Finally, I saw a post on Twitter\/X that said, \u201cPeople are mad Oasis and Phish aren\u2019t in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. But the Beatles and Grateful Dead already are. Why would we induct their tribute bands?\u201d That made me smile.<\/p>\n
Tim Wood<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I managed to buy a couple of pitch standing tickets for the recent Oasis show at Croke Park in Dublin. It is easily one of the best shows I have ever seen. What made it so special was the atmosphere. It was electric. The brilliant, sunny weather helped for sure and on the way into stadium all the local residents were outside their homes, sitting at tables, having a beer and chatting with everyone. It was just amazing.<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
The last song played over the PA before the band walked on was The Auld Triangle by The Dubliners. The whole stadium joined in. Incredible moment that nobody there will forget. It made the hair stand up on the back of my neck. And then the band walked on stage and delivered a cracking show\u2026\u2026..<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
I\u2019d go again in a heartbeat.<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
Best wishes to you and Felice!<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
Kind regards,<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
Brian Hand<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Amen.<\/p>\n
I have several friends driving up from St. Louis to Chicago. They are not music people. They have become Yacht Rock people who tried (sadly) to love their kids rap\/bro country music diet but would never see a show in anything but a stadium or an arena. I don\u2019t get them, they don\u2019t get me. The oldsters I love are still writing and recording new music. Oasis was irrelevant 5 years after their first album. Who has the time when there is so much good music out there?<\/p>\n
Mike Becker<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
You\u2019ll see people traveling from around the world to watch them at the rose bowl. They\u2019re massive in Asia and Latin America. Oh, and listen to the Masterplan album from beginning to end and you\u2019ll see\/hear how Noel can write tunes for days and knows which ones he should sing vs. Liam. They\u2019re a juggernaut on this tour. I saw it first hand in Manchester and London, but I reckon they\u2019ll bring that same vibe everywhere they go. The band is playing great and the brothers are in their prime.<\/p>\n
Darrin Holender<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I saw them in a club in London around 1993, I think before they signed to Creation, but for sure before they had a publishing deal or a record released. I was running EMI Publishing Canada and was in London for one of Marty\u2019s quarterly Managing Director\u2019s conferences. Guy and the A&R staff invited me along to see this \u201cnew band with a buzz\u201d. Can\u2019t remember the club but it was a typical rat hole where the band didn\u2019t even have a stage. They were drunk out of their minds, I didn\u2019t know any of the songs, and it was one of the greatest things I\u2019ve ever seen in a club.<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
Michael McCarty<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I saw every Oasis headline show in LA from the Feb 1995 show at the Palace to the final LA show at Staples in 2009 which had curtains over most of the upper deck.\u00a0 \u00a0I am just as amazed as you are that they can sell out the Rose Bowl twice when during their prime,\u00a0 they were only playing Universal.\u00a0 \u00a0I have watched videos from almost every show and the crowd is just insane singing along to every song.\u00a0 \u00a0Will be very curious to see how the US shows go because most of the people in attendance won’t know most of the songs.<\/p>\n
Steve Burnette<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Great article, well said. \u00a0I saw Oasis in Toronto in 2008, recognized 3 or 4 songs. \u00a0It was that it was on Toronto Island that made it cool.<\/p>\n
Ross Winters<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Seems on point to me. Saw them once on the 2000’s when one of my brothers had an extra ticket. Liked Wonderwall and Champagne Supernova but never bought an album. Didn\u2019t; nd still don’t know their music.<\/p>\n
Jet opened (remember them??) and were fun. Oasis actually were good even though I definitely didn’t know all the music.<\/p>\n
Am I going from Phoenix to LA or elsewhere to see Oasis? No. But I know a couple from there that went to Scotland to see them. My two oldest, who are 28 and 25, are flying from Denver and South Bend to go to a show with a second cousin who is 25 and lives in Pittsburgh to see Oasis at the Meadowlands (hard to call it MetLife Stadium) this weekend.<\/p>\n
The couple is nostalgia for sure. For my kids and cousin’s kid, all of whom are way into music, is it FOMO or a band they have gotten into and really like? Don’t know but they definitely play into the dynamics you describe.<\/p>\n
Cheers!<\/p>\n
Neal H. Bookspan<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Nailed it!<\/p>\n
Claudia Hirsch<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I became a diehard Oasis fan only after watching their 2016 documentary, Supersonic. I\u2019ve watched it easily 40 times since and can quote it with my band mates just like we do The Big Lebowski and Tombstone.<\/p>\n
The Gallagher\u2019s story is simply incredible. And utterly unique. And when you add the way Noel managed an abusive childhood with throwing himself into reading and guitars and songwriting, it\u2019s as inspiring (arguably more) as any member of the Beatles or U2 or The Eagles or Metallica.<\/p>\n
And yes, Oasis\u2019 impact and imprint in the UK is biblical.<\/p>\n
I would debate anyone that that documentary has grown their legend in North America far more than simply fans discovering or re-listening to only the music\u2026which is comprised of at least a half dozen timeless songs that rival any act on our American classic rock stations.<\/p>\n
Damon Johnson<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
A British friend in the business told me that Oasis tickets were so scarce (or expensive via brokers) in Europe that it was cheaper for European fans to fly to the USA to see a show. That could account for some of those stadium seats.<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
Floyd Dillman<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Oasis is only playing 5 shows in the US, a country of 330 million people and I agree with your assessment of Oasis market position in America.\u00a0 I am a fan and going to the Rose Bowl show with friends who are all Oasis fans, but the band is far from a household name.\u00a0 In fact, i had to convince my wife to come along\u00a0 as she asked, “What songs do they have besides Wonderwall”<\/p>\n
Hoping for the best, but I think it’s unlikely that the crowd sings more than a few songs in unison like we have been seeing form the social posts from the UK shows.<\/p>\n
Bill Gagnon<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
1. They are the youngest, most recent version of the \u201crock and roll stars\u201d of yesteryear. The Backstreet Boys hit only a couple years after Wonderwall debuted \u2014 and you as well as anyone else know the massive cultural shift that happened in America in 2000. Even the bands that survived the change of the millennium became pop bands that played rock music in a sense. Everything had a vinyl sheen on it. The confidence\/arrogance, quotable interviews, cigarettes in pictures, all that stuff you used to see from every band ever \u2014 Oasis were the last to do it. It\u2019s nostalgia for the Gen X\u2019s but an unattainable and delicious flavor for the kids. When has Harry Styles ever said \u201cwhere\u2019s the little c*** that makes me tea?\u201d on camera?<\/p>\n
2. Liam and Noel are both incredibly funny and terminally online people. Liam stayed relevant on Twitter the entire time he and his brother were doing their meaningless solo gigs. Staying relevant online + time to stew + big announcement = viral moment. And that viral moment has created the \u201cyou can\u2019t miss this\u201d feeling that you described. The younger generation is complicated and they have a lot of quirks but one thing they will absolutely not do is be left out of a moment deemed worthy of the internets eye.<\/p>\n
And for what it\u2019s worth, it\u2019s pretty cool for my elder millennial self to see a couple of dudes flipping the bird and playing without a click track again. You\u2019ve been saying for years about how authenticity sells and Oasis is nothing else if not purely, truly, unwaveringly authentic.<\/p>\n
– long time fan, Eric Henkels<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Greetings, Bob:<\/p>\n
Thank you for your note about Oasis. \u00a0I wondered, too, why you hadn’t included them in your piece about tours.<\/p>\n
I like the band well enough, but I’ve never been a fan, and I had no impulse to attend a show in Toronto, the nearest to me, not least because of the hubbub about the supposed crush to buy tickets to any or all of the performances on the tour.<\/p>\n
So it was more out of idle curiosity than any other impulse that I looked at the Ticketmaster site on Sunday, and I found the views for the show that night and the next. \u00a0Thousands attended, obviously, and most of the area not visible in these graphics, the far end of the venue\u2014the lower-priced seats, I gather\u2014were almost completely greyed out and sold out. \u00a0I was very surprised to see how many seats were still available in what look like pretty desirable regions, the stands on the side, angling on the stage, and the standing area. \u00a0 The blue dots were legitimate, first-sale tickets\u2014most, I saw, in the CAD500 or CAD300 range (compared to the CAD200 at the far end), which struck me as not inconceivable in the overheated, overpriced world of mega-concertgoing\u2014and the red ones resales, some on the order of CAD1,000, maybe one row in front of the CAD500 seat.<\/p>\n
Maybe there were gamblers who held out for discounted resales at the last minute, maybe people moved down, maybe hundreds of seat-fillers were bused in, but otherwise I’d have thought that these gaps would have been pretty evident.<\/p>\n
I looked at the Rose Bowl show on Ticketmaster, and found some resales, but no original sales available, and proportionally way fewer than in Toronto.<\/p>\n
So, what was up with Toronto? \u00a0I’m not at all doubting the bona fides of the fans who attended the show with you, nor the alcohol-fuelled verve they brought to the event, and the lads walked away with many, many thousands of Canadian dollars. But no sell-out. \u00a0Did they just reach their limit of punters who were willing to buy into the ticket frenzy?<\/p>\n
What ever can this mean?<\/p>\n
Thanks for your letters, Bob.<\/p>\n
All best,<\/p>\n
Blaine Allan<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I couldn\u2019t disagree more
\nIf you were correct and explain to me how they\u2019ve sold out Asia and central and South America in a nanosecond
\nI saw them in London, so yeah it\u2019s different but you didn\u2019t go to the pop-up store at the W hotel in Hollywood and see the frenzy to buy essentially garbage
\nYour comparison to Charlie Sheen is frankly not valid. I\u2019ll see him again in Los Angeles, but I will be pretty certain, but it will be the same largest karaoke sing-along just like it was in the Uk<\/p>\n
Mark Sanderson<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Going to see Oasis reminds us that we are like sheep…follow the herd. Fear of missing out.<\/p>\n
Gary Lawrence<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I gotta disagree with your Oasis take here (though I\u2019ll give you the solo material thing).<\/p>\n
I graduated high school in \u201895. Oasis was massive for Beatle freaks my age. I\u2019m Gen X, Bob. Forty-eight. Not dead. You said, \u201cWho was around who actually saw them?\u201d Uh\u2026 me, Bob. I saw them at the Stone Pony. I think \u201896-ish, right before the second album dropped. Liam spent half the set calling us wankers, told us we didn\u2019t deserve them, and stormed off with a \u201cf*ck off\u201d or something equally charming. It was glorious.<\/p>\n
So yeah, us 48-year-olds? We\u2019re still here. We\u2019re in our prime, Bob. Prime. And guess what? Next week, I\u2019m seeing Oasis again \u2014 MetLife Stadium. Sold out. Forty-eight and still in the pit.<\/p>\n
Maybe not the pit\u2026but still. PRIME.<\/p>\n
Anyway\u2026that second album was f*cking huge my freshman year of college \u2014 at least in Jersey. Felt like 92.3 K-Rock and MTV had those singles on an every ten-minute rotation through winter \u201896. \u00a0Honestly, I\u2019m just shocked those songs didn\u2019t chart higher.<\/p>\n
Keep writing, Bob!<\/p>\n
Baba-Booey.<\/p>\n
Rudy Falco<\/p>\n
Eatontown, NJ<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I\u2019m afraid I have to throw the \u201cyou\u2019re out of touch\u201d challenge flag, Bob.<\/p>\n
I have kids, now in their 20\u2019s, who have been obsessed with Oasis since\u00a0\u00a0they were mere single digits. At the time of the 2009 break-up.<\/p>\n
In recent times, I\u2019ve witnessed the lads and their pals crooning away in drunken glee to \u201cDon\u2019t Look Back in Anger\u201d, \u201cChampagne Supernova\u201d and the all-mighty \u201cWonderwall\u201d to name but a few.<\/p>\n
I\u2019m passing this time around because I saw Oasis on that same Black Crowes tour and later at Wembley Arena, a raucous show on my 50th birthday which aired live across MTV Europe about a year before they split. (Note-It can be found on YouTube)\u00a0\u00a0I witnessed the opening number, \u201cRock n\u2019 Roll Star\u201d, accompanied by what appeared to be a shower of flying pints of lager, but alas\u2026it was a different kind of golden brew.<\/p>\n
Now my sons were too young to see the Gallaghers and co. in their prime, so yeah maybe it\u2019s a bit of FOMO, but life\u2019s all about experience, their experience.\u00a0\u00a0And THAT\u2019s who\u2019s going and I\u2019m sending them!<\/p>\n
Bob, some equations aren\u2019t meant for us older folk to figure out.\u00a0\u00a0And this Oasis conundrum may just be one.<\/p>\n
Reminds me of Dennis Miller\u2019s quote on SNL Weekend Update when he wrote off the Mick Jagger and David Bowie \u201cDancing in the Streets\u201d video.\u00a0\u00a0\u201cMick, David? Why don\u2019t you go sit on the porch with some Country Time lemonade and let the kids play with the ball for awhile.\u201d<\/p>\n
Have a glass on me Bob. \ud83d\ude42 And by the way, I do hope Noel reads your entry and reacts. His acerbic response might just be the best \u201cmailbag\u201d email you\u2019ve ever gotten.<\/p>\n
Brian Diamond<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I saw Oasis last night in Toronto… still buzzing this morning… loud guitar rock with the audience dancing and singing\u00a0along song-after-song… just what\u00a0this mid-50’s kid needed!<\/p>\n
Dave Mason<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Longtime reader, first time responder. I think you might be missing the mark here. I’m old and my days of standing in gen pop in a sea of people have been pretty much behind me. However, on my recent trip to Edinburgh I caught Oasis at Murrayfield. I had seen them once before in the 90s at Roseland in NYC. I’ve never been a super fan but I thought they put on a great show at Roseland. But seeing them a few weeks ago on their home turf in the UK was next level. Spilled beer was dripping down the stairs and we were stepping over piles of puke on the way to our seats before they even started playing. From the first song to the last song there was such an energy – everyone was on their feet the entire time, hugging the strangers next to them and singing every word to every song at the top of their lungs. I found myself surprised by how many songs I knew\/ remembered and the band sounded FANTASTIC.<\/p>\n
No doubt the tour is a money grab and the pop up merch shops in each town prior to the show are left empty by the end of the day. You have to have an “appointment” just to get in the store, then wait in line and hope they have something left in your size. There has always been a cult around Oasis and with the recent hype of this tour I think you are underestimating their fandom and how many songs over the years of their absence music fans discovered and fell in love with. This was no “freak show.” Although I’ll admit I was curious how the brothers would get along on stage for 2 hours- but they put the crowd first. They got up there and put on a stellar show.<\/p>\n
As you know, everything is about the experience. When you have a band that is bringing it on stage and you are surrounded by people who have been waiting to hear these songs live for over a decade, its impossible to walk away not converted. I have many industry friends asking me how I got my tickets so they can secure some for their clients. I recommend reconsidering, don’t sit this one out.<\/p>\n
Debbie Wunder<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
I was a little bit surprised by your comments about Oasis. For someone who constantly laments that the business has become too cookie cutter like, your review had a very disappointingly conventional focus to it as well (e.g. only one or two big hits, record sales, bad show at the Whisky, etc.).<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
I am not quite sure if the quality of their music and past sales is the right lens to capture what is going on with them. I went to the two Cardiff shows and I would call what I experienced events rather than concerts. It is a small town with basically two streets of pubs next to the stadium. From the morning on every Pub was full, crowds spilling over on the street with Oasis songs blaring out. At the concert the energy of the crowd was electric, everybody singing along to every song (and yes, they have more than two). I still think about those two nights almost every day not because they were that great (if you would have put them at the Whisky those two nights it still would not have been good) but as Noel ones said, \u201cpeople will never forget of how you made them feel\u201d and they can do that better than most other acts.<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
Best,<\/p>\n
<\/p>\n
Claus te Wildt<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Hi Bob, I went to the second of two sold out shows in front of 50,000 people last night in Toronto. Simply a magnificent return to form with incredible production that truly brought all of their songs to life. It wasn\u2019t just old farts from the 90\u2019s but people from all age groups and from every walk of life. It was an immersive experience from the second you walked on the outside of the stadium grounds. They had their PA pumping relatively obscure songs that were all UK bands from the 60\u2019s and 70\u2019s. The Kinks – See My Friends, Free – Wishing Well, Rory Gallagher – Country Mile from the Calling Card album, Jimi Hendrix – If Six Was Nine, Geordie (Brian Johnson\u2019s pre AC DC band) – Natural Born Loser, The Heavy Metal Kids – Hangin\u2019 on, Earl Vince and the Valiants – \u00a0Somebody\u2019s Gonna Get Their Head Kicked in tonight and then blasting Neil Young – Keep On Rocking in the Free World before hitting the stage. It made it even more exciting! I paid \u00a0face value of $312.00 for a ticket and it was worth every penny. Unlike Some of the bands you mentioned that do the same rounds year after year in many cities in the US, Oasis are only doing East Rutherford, Chicago and LA, and the major select cities globally between now and the end of the year. A big something for the millions that want to\u00a0go. I dreaded being 320,000th in line when I tried to log in on the dates being announced, but in the end I got a ticket! The Dave Matthews band, are minimal at best outside of the US, Oasis are global through and through. You and any other non believers will be kicking yourself if you don\u2019t go to one of these shows!<\/p>\n
Ivar Hamilton
\nNiagara on the Lake, Ontario<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
From a big Oasis fan. 40yo.<\/p>\n
I saw them at the Ryman in 2006. Loved it.<\/p>\n
But I will say the only reason why I\u2019m scheming to try and see them this time is the notion that it could be their last go around. And that\u2019s probably true for most. They wouldn\u2019t be booking stadiums in the US if they were planning on touring the states every year or two.<\/p>\n
An act can only wait fifteen years between touring cycles a couple times in their career.<\/p>\n
But it sure is exciting.<\/p>\n
And the reports I\u2019ve got back from the Toronto shows were that \u2018I\u2019ve never heard so many people sing every word to every song\u2019\u2026so we\u2019ll see if that makes it south.<\/p>\n
Side note\u2026Oasis released about 60 b-sides throughout their career but the ones from the 90\u2019s could have been another huge album. I cherry picked 14 of them the other day.\u00a0https:\/\/open.spotify.com\/playlist\/58eH1yuOqVMOj9V1GfU1Ib?si=a584e9819aa1403e<\/p>\n
Gabe Anderson<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Great piece! I think you\u2019re missing something \u2026 or I am! lol<\/p>\n
I saw Oasis twenty years ago in 2005 when a friend took me to their sold out show at MSG. I went in casually aware of their music, and I left a fan. You\u2019re right that they don\u2019t move much on stage, they didn\u2019t have a light show to speak of, but they were captivating anyway. They\u2019ve got a charisma that is akin to what Jon Anderson of Yes has. I just couldn\u2019t stop focusing on them, and I can\u2019t tell you why. I love that.<\/p>\n
After that show I told my family I\u2019d take them to see Oasis some day so they could experience it. Well. It took twenty years and a trip to Toronto from our home in New Hampshire, but it happened. My 20-something kids knew more of the words than I did. The crowd around us (from Canada, Texas, New York, and England) knew all of the words, too. And we stood shoulder-to-shoulder and sang \u201cStand By Me\u201d and \u201cLive Forever\u201d in the pouring rain like it was the only thing that mattered.<\/p>\n
And, in the moment, it was.<\/p>\n
Obviously not every band is for every person. That\u2019s the beauty of music. I\u2019m also a Rush fan and a Phish fan, so I definitely grok what it\u2019s like to enjoy a band that the majority dislikes or has no interest in.<\/p>\n
Is there FOMO out there about missing Oasis\u2019s reunion tour? Sure thing. But they\u2019re putting on shows with power and meaning, too. And they sound great doing it, at least from where our seats were in Section 103 of Rogers Stadium the other night.<\/p>\n
The real question, to your point, is: how long will they be able to keep this going? And how long will the Brothers Gallagher *want* to keep it going?<\/p>\n
We\u2019ll find out, I\u2019m sure! Whether they on stage or off, those boys sure know how to command attention!<\/p>\n
-Dave Hamilton
\nHost of Gig Gab, Mac Geek Gab, and Business Brain podcasts.<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
So glad you wrote about this. When I heard Oasis was back together and coming to Chicago I thought they would be playing chicago theatre not soldier field! Really?!? Make it make sense!<\/p>\n
Nathan B.<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
August 1994 at Wetlands in Tribeca – their first U.S.\u00a0show. I was an unpaid summer intern at Sony Music. No money but I saw a ton of free shows that summer. If memory serves, Lisa Loeb opened. I remember they were loud and rude. I loved the later stuff. But your characterization of them as essentially niche here is spot on.<\/p>\n
Hope all\u2019s well.<\/p>\n
Best,<\/p>\n
Edward Ryan<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
Classic Boomer attitude Bob. I deal with guys like you everyday in my Beatles tribute band. If Oasis truly was ever as big as the Beatles, I\u2019d be so much happier singing their songs than She Loves You for the nine thousandth time, to people who for some reason keep paying to see Gen Xer\u2019s wear wigs and essentially make fun of your St. John Lennon.<\/p>\n
It\u2019s rock and roll baby. We\u2019re all in it for the money.<\/p>\n
Long time reader, keep it up!<\/p>\n
Piss off,<\/p>\n
Nate Bott<\/p>\n
_____________________________________<\/p>\n
You know what I like about OASIS’ newly released 9-CD set, ‘The Complete Studio Album Collection\u2019? (2025) I\u2019ll tell ya what I like about it. It\u2019s NO frills!!! NO muddy half-ass demo takes (that I’ll play once, then shelve), no gawd-awful \u2018duets\u2019, no marbles or stickers or goofy packaging-filler that no one wants or needs, and no banal critic writing multiple pages in a booklet trying to place the band in some sort of historical context\u2026Just the studio albums as they were originally released & intended. And all gathered together in one handy-dandy box. And if I really need any extra B-side cuts that weren\u2019t on \u2018The Masterplan\u2019 collection, I\u2019ve got a stellar O.G. \u2018Morning Glory\u2019 Singles Box from back in the day for posterity.<\/p>\n
Am I gonna make any of the U.S. shows? Uhh, let\u2019s just say, \u2018Definitely Maybe\u2019? But more likely, NOT. I saw them half a dozen times the first time around in smaller venues, like the Fillmore in S.F. Not the most \u2018action-packed\u2019 band I\u2019ve ever seen live. (Note the many moving cameras & spliced edits on their live videos.) If I had the extra bones (& foresight) I would\u2019ve definitely gone to Cardiff to experience those crowds though! That looked pretty electric. I\u2019m thinking U.S. crowds will be WAY more subdued. But hey, if I know of anyone who IS going to the Rose Bowl, (of which, I currently don’t), I genuinely hope they have a fulfilling time.\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n You’re right Bob, all the clips we keep seeing showing the Gallaghers hugging & high-fiving along with feel-good, ecstatic crowds shots, are meant to keep the momentum going until the tours end. And hey, who can blame them? That’s just good marketing. However, at age 60, I\u2019m WAAAYYY more choosy about which shows I’ll go out & see (preferably Troubadour, Largo & Roxy type venues). So as ‘Rock & Roll Star’ echoes through the canyons, I’ll most likely be kickin\u2019 back with the Studio Albums set,\u00a0cranking\u00a0\u2018Slide Away’ &\/or ‘Underneath The Sky\u2019 and singin\u2019 along to me\u00a0heart’s\u00a0content in the comfort of my ol’ music room.\u00a0<\/span><\/p>\n Much love, Bob!<\/p>\n Mark Atherlay<\/p>\n Burbank, CA.<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n The Beatles of the 90\u2019s.<\/p>\n Everyone else f*ck off.<\/p>\n Jimmy Becker<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n So you\u2019re not an Oasis fan. Got it.<\/p>\n I\u2019ll be enjoying my second show of the tour this Sunday at MetLife, a follow up to their July 25th show at Wembley.<\/p>\n I respect your takes on most artists, specifically when it comes to recognizing the song comes first. You\u2019ve missed the mark here, minimizing them to two songs basically. Give your infatuation with new country music a breather and revisit the current Oasis setlist. It rocks.<\/p>\n Dave L<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n Your instincts have not failed you Bob; Oasis is Muzak for the pop rock crowd of a certain sort. \u00a0Next please, we\u2019ll be in touch.<\/p>\n Dvae Dalzell<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n Right on the money, as usual\u2026.<\/p>\n Or as Noel would say, \u201cSOD OFF!!\u201d<\/p>\n sean michael dargan<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n Thanks for clearing that up. I couldn\u2019t understand what all of the hysteria has been\u00a0 about this tour. I never cared about Oasis before and I still don\u2019t.<\/p>\n Harold Love<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n I was sorta shocked and more curious why all my friends were dying to fly so far to see them in England, etc. I love the band but don\u2019t remember the stadium level hype back in the day. They were huge but not stadium huge.\u00a0 Saw them in Oakland while back tickets were easy to get. I do\u00a0think this a trend we\u00a0will continue to see going forward as bands stay away long enough, only to reunite and play bigger venues then they ever had before.\u00a0 Or at least Coachella for an insane amount of money.<\/p>\n Noah Bailin<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n Its the changing of the guard for nostalgia.<\/p>\n <\/p>\n The Stones, Elton, et al grew their stadium businesses of the back of boomers flush with disposable cash once their Gen X kids were off their payroll and they were taking their kids to see the idols of their youth.<\/p>\n <\/p>\n The same is happening with Oasis only now its the Gen X’ers who have the disposable cash and they’re\u00a0taking their\u00a0Gen Z kids.<\/p>\n <\/p>\n Unlike the boomers, Gen Xers grew up going to festivals, stadium shows and club culture thanks to the explosion of alternative & dance music. Not that much has changed in terms of that\u00a0experience\u00a0which means culturally the generation gap is closer with Gen X & Gen Z than Gen X and Boomers. _____________________________________<\/p>\n Long time lurker\u2026.rather, regular reader – I\u2019ve enjoyed your work, your opinions and your erudition for nearly a decade.<\/p>\n And I find myself compelled to respond for the first time following your Oasis post this evening.<\/p>\n Full disclosure, I\u2019m a Brit. Lived in Manchester in the 90s, within spitting distance of the old Maine Road stadium (where Man City used to play when they were sh*t but when die-hards like the Gallaghers and me supported them).<\/p>\n And I queued up at midnight outside HMV to get my hands on What\u2019s the Story\u2026.Morning Glory.<\/p>\n Oasis were part of my town, my city, my life. I saw them play a bunch of times. And\u2026.fast forward a few years, I was at the gig in Paris where they split up.<\/p>\n But after Morning Glory, let\u2019s be honest, the rest of their albums were rubbish.<\/p>\n Sure, there was a tune here or there, but most of their work was self-indulgent, drug fuelled crap. So I stopped buying them. As did most of my friends and peer group.<\/p>\n But I never stopped listening to the first two albums and some of the B-sides.<\/p>\n I\u2019ve been living in Canada for 15 yrs and went to see Oasis last night in Toronto.<\/p>\n I wasn\u2019t originally planning to…<\/p>\n Well, actually that\u2019s not strictly true.<\/p>\n When they announced the tour and that they would be coming to Toronto, I signed up for the fan club so I could get early access tickets. I put the time and date in the calendar and was in the queue at Ticketmaster.<\/p>\n But the prices were f*cking ridiculous.<\/p>\n I saw Oasis destroy the Manchester Academy in the 1990s for 20 quid. The cheapest floor tickets (I\u2019m not going up in the Gods) were over 700 dollars. So I passed.<\/p>\n But this week, ahead of the gig, I thought I\u2019d check Stubhub. Those same tickets were now $300.<\/p>\n I\u2019d pay that.<\/p>\n So I did.<\/p>\n I\u2019m going to be 50 next year. Nearly 10 years younger than Noel.<\/p>\n But I was almost the oldest person there last night.<\/p>\n Yep – that\u2019s right.<\/p>\n This gig was the biggest f*cking singalong I have ever been to. 50,000 people and every single person knew every word.<\/p>\n And most of them hadn\u2019t been born when Supersonic came out.<\/p>\n There were a smattering of teenagers with their parents, but the vast majority of the crowd were in their 20s and early 30s.<\/p>\n Oasis might not have sold many records and they certainly didn\u2019t get a lot of MTV, but who gives a f*ck?!<\/p>\n Just like every 17 yr old girl today can quote you most of the punchlines from Friends because of Netflix, there\u2019s a whole army of fans who know every single f*cking word to over two hours of Oasis songs (trusted, they only played the good ones). And who weren\u2019t born when the songs were recorded.<\/p>\n Oasis don\u2019t and won\u2019t ever cast a shadow on the creative talent of John and Paul, but they\u2019ve done something that only the Beatles have managed – creating generations who know every f*cking word. Every single f*cking word of every song. And who are prepared to pay hundreds of dollars to stand in the rain to belt them out for two hours.<\/p>\n And for that\u2026.respect.<\/p>\n Thanks Bob. Keep on keeping on.<\/p>\n Jon Duschinsky<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n Bob, Just got this email earlier today. Don’t miss out!<\/p>\n “A limited number of production release tickets have been made available for Oasis Live ’25 North American dates for the Rosebowl, Los Angeles.”<\/p>\n Ed Arias<\/p>\n _____________________________________<\/p>\n In 1992 when I was President of Epic Records in NY David Massey and I signed Oasis. We had been to see them play a small pub in London and blown away.<\/p>\n We brought them over for promotion on their first album and took them to a pizza place for dinner and to meet the team. Liam over enjoyed himself and Noel grilled me for two hours about how to break America.<\/p>\n They broke America because of the great music but also because they worked their arses off going round the States do promo and playing gigs. Went to see them play Wembley stadium. Incredible show.<\/p>\n I\u2019m flying out to go to NY shows and we are having an Epic Records reunion. Just about everyone who worked there in the mid 90s is coming!<\/p>\n Go and see them in LA. You will be blown away!<\/p>\n Richard Griffiths<\/p>\n <\/p>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":" Astute. I have experienced Oasis in small clubs, and we also did a live broadcast on WBCN from the Orpheum Theatre when the band played Boston. Exceedingly dull performances every appearance. One boring band with a few good songs. Give me Blur any day. Oedipus _____________________________________ I agree with everything you said about Oasis. I […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":"","jetpack_publicize_message":"","jetpack_publicize_feature_enabled":true,"jetpack_social_post_already_shared":true,"jetpack_social_options":{"image_generator_settings":{"template":"highway","default_image_id":0,"font":"","enabled":false},"version":2}},"categories":[3,6],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-22376","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-live-shows","category-the-music"],"jetpack_publicize_connections":[],"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","jetpack_shortlink":"https:\/\/wp.me\/p96vPs-5OU","jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/22376","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=22376"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/22376\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":22377,"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/22376\/revisions\/22377"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=22376"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=22376"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/lefsetz.com\/wordpress\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=22376"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}
\nMichael Richardson<\/p>\n
\nI think you\u2019re a bit dismissive of the millions of albums they sold!<\/p>\n